Past the Euro-Atlantic Consensus
As Russia's full-scale invasion enters its fifth yr, Ukraine has proven extraordinary resilience. On the battlefield, Ukrainian forces have denied Moscow a decisive victory. At residence, society continues to operate regardless of day by day assaults. Diplomatically, regardless of uncertainties coming from Washington, Kyiv has secured sturdy political, navy, and monetary backing from most of Europe and North America.
But, past the Euro-Atlantic house, the image is extra complicated. In a lot of Africa, Asia, and Latin America, Ukraine has typically encountered cautious engagement reasonably than clear political alignment. Many governments have condemned violations of sovereignty in precept, however have averted deeper engagement.
When Battle Turns into Routine
Because the conflict enters its fifth yr, one other structural problem emerges: normalization. Within the first months of Russia's full-scale invasion, photos of destroyed cities and displaced civilians dominated international headlines. Immediately, significantly in areas geographically distant from Europe, the conflict more and more dangers turning into a part of the background of worldwide politics. It dangers being absorbed right into a crowded international agenda marked by conflicts within the Center East, tensions surrounding Iran, and intensifying US–China rivalry.
This normalization doesn’t essentially sign assist for Moscow. It displays distance, urgent home priorities, and a crowded international agenda formed by financial instability, local weather pressures, nice energy pressure, and regional conflicts. Nonetheless, the political impact is critical. When a conflict turns into routine, neutrality carries fewer reputational prices. For Ukraine, which means that engagement with the International South can’t rely solely on ethical readability or authorized precept; it requires persistent diplomacy that frequently explains why the results of territorial conquest in Europe prolong far past the area.
Recognizing this hole throughout wartime requires strategic readability. Lengthy wars take a look at not solely navy energy but in addition diplomatic stamina. International locations of the International South might not present navy or monetary help on the dimensions of Ukraine's European companions, but their significance shouldn’t be underestimated. Their demographic weight, regional management, and voting energy in multilateral establishments give them important affect over how the conflict is mentioned and understood globally. Partaking persistently with nations akin to Indonesia, Brazil, and India issues as a result of they form regional agendas and broader coalitions throughout the growing world. Sustained diplomatic outreach to those states strengthens Ukraine's international place over the long run.
Totally different Political Grammars
One motive for the cautious stance in elements of the International South lies within the language of diplomacy. Ukraine's worldwide messaging has understandably targeted on defending the rules-based order, democratic solidarity, and European safety. These arguments resonate powerfully in Brussels, Paris, Berlin, and doubtless Washington. They’re morally and legally sound.
Nevertheless, in lots of societies formed by decolonization, non-alignment, and improvement struggles, political discourse follows a special grammar. Historic reminiscence in these areas is marked by colonial domination, Chilly Battle intervention, and uneven international hierarchies. Overseas coverage is usually guided much less by institutional alignment and extra by sovereignty, autonomy, and financial stability. In some circumstances, cautious positioning displays deliberate strategic hedging for autonomy, reasonably than easy misperception.
A Lesson from Jakarta
Indonesia gives a telling instance. It’s the largest nation in Southeast Asia, a G20 member, and a number one voice within the International South. But Ukraine's diplomatic presence there has lacked continuity. The Ukrainian embassy in Jakarta has been with out a resident ambassador since February 2025. At a time when sustained engagement is important, extended gaps in high-level illustration ship an unintended sign about priorities.
Diplomacy just isn’t solely about UN votes or official statements. It’s about presence, relationships, and constant engagement. In Indonesia, as in different elements of the International South, political affect is constructed over time by universities, youth organizations, media networks, and civil society platforms. With out secure management and institutional depth, principally coming from the Ukrainian representatives there, outreach stays episodic and perceived as a "one-off occasion".
Presence Over Statements
On the similar time, Russia has invested in long-term narratives. Moscow frequently invokes historic ties relationship again to Soviet-era cooperation with post-colonial states. In Indonesia, Russia emphasizes shared recollections of Chilly Battle solidarity, protection cooperation, and academic exchanges. Russian cultural outreach, media content material, and scholarship packages goal youthful generations, shaping perceptions step by step reasonably than by headline diplomacy alone. This method displays a long-standing Russian understanding that affect in post-colonial societies is constructed by reminiscence, training, and narrative continuity reasonably than short-term political or financial incentives.
This distinction is telling. Ukraine and lots of of its Western companions have a tendency to focus on official positions, encouraging governments to take clearer public stances and to uphold worldwide norms persistently. Russia, by comparability, invests patiently on the societal stage. It reinforces narratives of historic closeness, expands cultural and academic packages, and targets youthful generations by long-term outreach. Affect in these contexts is constructed much less by statements and extra by sustained presence and familiarity over time.
Recalibrating Ukraine's International Message
Luckily, there’s nonetheless house for recalibration.
First, Ukraine can extra intentionally join its wrestle to anti-imperial traditions that resonate throughout a lot of the International South. Russia's aggression is a transparent case of territorial conquest geared toward undermining borders, identification, and political company. In lots of African and Asian states, sovereignty was achieved by tough struggles towards empire. Presenting Ukraine's resistance in that context speaks on to historic experiences that stay politically highly effective immediately. On the similar time, messaging that frames the conflict primarily as a protection of "European civilization" might resonate strongly inside Europe however can unintentionally create distance elsewhere, the place audiences don’t see themselves mirrored in that narrative. A broader framing centered on sovereignty and resistance to domination travels extra successfully throughout areas.
Second, diplomatic messaging ought to persistently deal with materials penalties. For a lot of governments in Africa, Asia, and Latin America, meals safety, fertilizer provide, power volatility, and debt vulnerability are fast political considerations. The disruption of Ukrainian grain exports affected markets far past Europe. Demonstrating how Ukraine's survival contributes to international meals stability and financial predictability makes the conflict related to home priorities.
Third, sturdy relationships require long-term institutional presence. Excessive-level visits and symbolic summits matter, however they can’t change regular, on-the-ground engagement. Sturdy embassies with secure management, expanded educational exchanges, partnerships with native media, youth initiatives, and Monitor II dialogues in key regional hubs assist construct familiarity and belief over time. That is additionally an space the place Ukraine's allies can play a constructive function. Companions akin to the UK, the European Union, and EU member states like Poland typically have deeper institutional networks and long-standing ties in elements of Africa, Asia, and Latin America. Coordinated outreach may help Ukraine entry platforms, strengthen connections, and interact potential companions extra successfully. Constant presence, supported by coalition diplomacy, alerts long-term dedication.
Fourth, outreach ought to acknowledge regional variety. The International South just isn’t a single political bloc. In elements of Africa, sovereignty is usually mentioned when it comes to safety from exterior intervention. In a lot of Asia, stability and financial progress dominate strategic pondering. In Latin America, resistance to great-power coercion carries explicit weight. Tailor-made narratives display attentiveness with out compromising precept.
Conclusion: Narrative as Strategic Terrain
None of this implies distancing Ukraine from Europe or weakening the ethical readability of its trigger. Ukraine's strongest asset stays the legitimacy of its wrestle towards unprovoked aggression. The target is to not alter that substance, however to speak it in ways in which resonate throughout totally different political and historic contexts.
Latest expertise in Indonesia illustrates how simply diplomatic engagement might be reframed in aggressive data environments. A proper communication from the Ukrainian Embassy, meant to convey Ukraine's place, was publicly portrayed by the Russian ambassador as interference in Indonesian home affairs. No matter intent, such episodes create openings for counter-narratives and shift consideration away from the central problem of Russian aggression. In nations the place sovereignty is a deeply guarded precept, even well-intentioned strain might be recast as exterior intrusion.
Whereas Ukrainian victory on this conflict will proceed to rely upon navy energy, financial resilience, and political unity, it can additionally rely upon whether or not Ukraine can maintain belief and credibility far past its fast companions. In lots of elements of the International South, perceptions are formed step by step, by long-term presence and cautious engagement. Defending Ukraine's narrative from distortion and making certain that its wrestle is known by itself phrases is not peripheral diplomacy. It’s a part of the conflict itself.
Radityo Dharmaputra, a lecturer in Worldwide Relations at Universitas Airlangga, Indonesia, a senior researcher on the college's Centre for European and Eurasian Research
Leave a Reply