Ukraine’s Anti-Corruption Bureau uncovers over US$17.8m embezzlement scheme at Defence Ministry

On 2 April, Ukraine’s Nationwide Anti-Corruption Bureau (NABU) and the Specialised Anti-Corruption Prosecutor’s Workplace (SAPO) uncovered a corruption scheme involving over UAH 733 million (approx. US$17.8 million) in embezzled funds throughout meals procurement for the Armed Forces in 2022-2023. The scheme concerned a Defence Ministry official and affiliated suppliers.

Supply: NABU

Particulars: Prices have been introduced in opposition to a former head of a division throughout the Ministry of Defence, the proprietor of affiliated provide firms, two firm executives and one other particular person who took half within the embezzlement of state funds throughout meals procurement for the Armed Forces amid Russia’s full-scale invasion.

Their actions are being investigated underneath Articles 191.5 (misappropriation, embezzlement or conversion or property by malversation), 15.2 (legal try) at the side of 191.5, and 209.3 (legalisation (laundering) of criminally obtained cash and different property) of the Legal Code of Ukraine.

Investigators discovered that in 2022–2023, meals provides for the army had been organized through pre-assembled "meals kits" chosen from a listing of 409 gadgets. Nonetheless, solely 10% of these merchandise – equivalent to greens, grains, meat and water – had been repeatedly ordered. The remainder, together with spices, gelatine or berries, had been not often or by no means ordered resulting from their seasonal nature.

Quote from NABU: "This method allowed suppliers to govern costs – artificially inflating the price of high-demand merchandise whereas decreasing costs for unpopular or seasonal merchandise (equivalent to cherries or apricots in winter). At first look, there have been no violations, as the overall value of the package remained unchanged. Nonetheless, potatoes, equipped in hundreds of tonnes, break the bank, whereas seasonal berries and fruits, which had been not often ordered, had been priced at mere pennies."

Extra particulars: Between August and December 2022, two firms underneath one proprietor earned over US$17.8 million in extra earnings utilizing this scheme, as confirmed by knowledgeable evaluation. A few of the funds had been then funnelled out underneath the guise of dividends and monetary support to associated companies. Investigators suspect the cash was used to buy accommodations in Croatia and different property.

The corruption was enabled by a Defence Ministry official who allegedly ignored the anomalous costs listed within the catalogue whereas signing off on contracts.

Following the beginning of the pre-trial investigation in January 2023 – and after widespread media studies, together with these about eggs allegedly costing UAH 17 (approx. US$0.41) apiece – the scheme’s individuals decreased costs for the 11 most in-demand merchandise, stopping an extra US$19.2 million in funds losses.

Background:

• On 21 January 2023, ZN.ua media outlet reported that Ukraine’s Defence Ministry was buying meals for servicemen at costs two to a few instances greater than Kyiv outlets had been charging. The December contract with the meals firm was signed on behalf of the ministry by Bohdan Khmelnytskyi, then head of the State Procurement Division on the Ministry of Defence of Ukraine, who was concerned in a case of embezzlement of US$580,000 throughout the procurement of army ammunition.
• Public outrage erupted over a journalist investigation that cited the notorious "UAH 17 per egg" determine. On the time, the Defence Ministry referred to as the story manipulative and deceptive, after which Defence Minister Oleksii Reznikov denied wrongdoing. He later admitted in an interview with Ukrainska Pravda that he had reacted too emotionally and promised to confirm the journalists’ findings.
• Deputy Defence Minister Viacheslav Shapovalov resigned on 24 January amid the scandal, and Khmelnytskyi was dismissed from his submit as procurement division head the next day.
• Prime Minister Denys Shmyhal later ordered a reform of the procurement system for the Armed Forces, requiring value disclosures for meals and items.
• The Defence Ministry of Ukraine said that it’s collaborating with regulation enforcement companies to remove the dangers of corruption in procurement for the Armed Forces, whereas concurrently implementing a brand new NATO-standard procurement structure.

Help Ukrainska Pravda on Patreon!